Originally posted by aldudeau i saw it three nights go BLOODY GREAT!!!! kevin go and see it if u havent already Yep I see it mate.. heres my prob .. and before you all shout at me - hear me out Right on the good side: 1. Creatures where awesome (well most) 2. Animation was spot on (well most again) 3. Scenery was awesome!!!!!! 4. The chick was nice looking! 5. Some parts of the film where very well done 6. Gollum was fantastic (but see below) Bad points: 1. That dam tree scene where them 2 dudes where carried about aimlessley was sooo boring, simply no need for it - that scene could of been done in 3 mins - plus the trees looked crap - and what the hell did they do? I reakon I could have cut and pasted in photoshop more realistic then that!! - Pippin looked at times like he was floating in mid air. 2. The "whole" film was so drawn out. I was nearly alseep aside the main action scenes. 3. The main wizard guy just "reappearing" was crazy! In stead of drawing out the tree scene so much they maybe should of done something with this part to make it more believable. 4. 10 thousand bad guys break through the gates and still cant defeat 80 people!! 5. Did they steal gollum from else where as I swear I have seen it plus other points that I wont mention ---------------------------------------------------------- I guess in a nut shell - I just dont like these drawn out films, I like it over in 90 mins