Of course you cant duplicate the image, two different renderer's operating in different ways. All this about duplicating is stupid, and everyone else being an ass isn't helping.
Star - Overestimating s/w, underestimating Maxwell
Turbo - taking a misjudgment too personally
As recommended before, all you need is weed!
I don't know much about renderer's b/c I'm fairly new to this but its just my views from reading this highly entertaining thread!