I voted for fredrikkson as I liked the atmosphere he created and I felt the scene had a 'story' to it that all the elements contributed to.

I liked both models though (I was slightly frightened of the invasion of the hairy bath mat though Vector!).

I was impressed by the way both of you managed to get the porcelain effect on the sink and bath and capture that rounded bathroom - ware feel.

The little details like taps and plugs etc in both models were just right imho. Good work by both.