Rotate an edge but only move the affected vertices on a given axis?
 

Hi all,

I am trying to model the following simple structure:
http://s159880906.online.de/mayaproblem/example1.jpg
I made this example by creating a new polygonal cylinder, rotating the right edges and repositioning the affected vertices afterwards, but doing it that way just doesnt feel right, it seems too unclean to me.

I would like the affected vertices to only move on a given axis when rotating the edge, so I dont need to reposition them after the rotate operation. I tried to illustrate what I mean in the following screenshot:
http://s159880906.online.de/mayaproblem/example2.jpg
The edge I want to rotate is marked in red, the vertices that are supposed to only move on the y-axis are marked in green. The arrows indicate the desired movement.

Is this way of rotating possible with the rotate tool or something?

What your describing isn't really a roatation its a translation with a linear fall off to your pivot. You just want to be able to describe this translation with a rotation.

There isn't something which maya will support though you could probably do it with a soft modification though it wouldn't give you a rotation handle.

If you use a soft modification deformer and place a locator at your pivot with a look at constraint toward the soft mod deformer you will be able to get an angle feedback of your translation.

I already thought about that. I just wasn't sure whether it was possible to keep the angles between the edges that I want to rotate at 180° so I dont unintentionally bend them.

Though tedious you can do this with simple calcs. Using the angle required you can calculate each right traingle per vert and then move them up in the Y axis, I use the "Show CV' table in the attribute editor. I think this is what you mean? Maya. as Laurie has said doesnt have this function. I have tried many ways to get co planar or co linear points to work in Maya and the above method is the only one I have found thus far.

Cheers bullet

You could use the cut face tool then delete the edges that are not needed then just delete top faces select the top edge extrude then merge to centre just a case of snapping the center vert to the straight edge............dave

Unfortunately maya does not support falloffs as some other modeling apps do and the soft selection tool only selects spherical regions of action so we have to do this manually.

First we must accept that maya is not a cad program and so in most cases close enough is good enough.

I have made a fast video showing how to use manual brute force to get the linear falloff you are seeking.

Then I demonstrate the method Daverave suggested using the cut faces tool and a variation on that method that gives a bit more control.


howto manual linear falloff using the lattice deformer - YouTube

Nice one Rick have not gone into the cut face tool option nice to see how they work....................dave

Thank you Dave.

As I thought about this I realize you could also do this with a boolean! Yes! I said the B-word. This method is actually quite efficient.

howto manual linear falloff using boolean difference - YouTube

Thanks for the ideas ctbram and daverave, that looks very promising and big thanks for the instruction videos.

btw: I'm still pretty new to modeling techniques, so what is so bad about boolean operations?
**edit: Well, as I just discovered, boolean operations can create pretty messy meshes...

OT: I already love this forum :happy:

Nice one Rick Im with dave on the cut face option...I didnt know it was there. It was meant to be 65° too mate LOL 90-25=65...other than that nice tut and way better than a vert by vert solution like mine.

cheers bullet

I notice you cannot snap the cut tool to verts but you can snap to the grid Rick? why would this be. I guess you could cheat and snap your model to the required position first then cut.

cheers bullet

Sorry for the maths error. That is quite embarrassing considering I have a minor in Mathematics. lol

Hi Subsurf [and everyone else!]

I put together a quick video with another method using a Non-Linear Flare deformer that may help, you can find it at the following link;

Maya - Non-linear Flare - YouTube

Cheers!

Simon

PS - the quality is better [HD720] if you view it directly on Youtube!
PPS - forgot to mention in the video that when you're done, select the cylinder and go to Edit>Delete by Type>History to lock the shape in place and remove the deformer!

Interesting priimate, it would be nice if Maya just had a simple snap to polyline wouldnt it?

cheers bullet

Some good suggestions. As Rick said its not a cad program.

Personally I'd either cut the faces as daverave suggested or line up a polyplane and snap the verts accordingly. Maya is pretty lame at these type of 'edits'.

Keep it simple, usually thats the answer

Jay