Simply Maya User Community
Page 1 of 2 1 2

Simply Maya User Community (
-   1 On 1 Battles (
-   -   JrWho vs. Joopson (

26-09-2011 01:43 AM

JrWho vs. Joopson
Hey guys,

My name is Steven Palmesano and my buddy who is going to join me for this friendly competition is Andrew Leslie. We both started using Maya at around the same time (I started in 2006). However, I was young and stupid and did not take 3D art as seriously as I should have. Now that I only have a year left in school I realize the need to be more serious about my artwork so I have decided to get back onto forums.

The reason we are doing this is because we are both on break and have some free time. Instead of partying and relaxing, I thought it would be better to work on a project. We are going to start this competition on Tuesday, 9/27. Here are the rules we have decided on:

•Environment related
•CGSociety, Polycount, and SimplyMaya forums
•Begin time is 8/9 AM (CST/EST) and end time is 8/9 PM
•WIP shots can be posted as frequently as the gentleman wants to post them
•Final images are to be posted before this deadline, no exceptions
•Topic for voting will be made shortly after the competition is finished, with the final renders from both of us
•Voting period is three days, so it will approximately end on 9/30 at 8/9 PM
•Winner is determined by the sum of the sites' total votes combined
•No work can be done on the project prior to the starting time
•No previous models can be implemented
•References can be collected before start time
•How the artist presents his work is up to him
•No PaintFX!

However, we have not decided on a defined topic yet. I wanted to do some kind of animal hybrid with mechanical elements. Andy did not think this was as cool as I did though, so I brought up the alternative of doing an interior scene. We thought it was best to leave the decision of a topic up to the community, so you guys can decide what you want us to do! I am short on time tonight, but I wanted to get this topic out there. If anyone wants to know anything else or has a recommendation, please do not keep quiet!

Steven Palmesano

Gen 26-09-2011 03:00 AM

Ha! Cool. A friendly CG slap fight here and there is good stuff. Since its environment related, maybe an alien world, that can be hard surface/ organic friendly. This challenge sounds good, I'll be watching :)

Acid44 26-09-2011 05:36 AM

Having seen some of Joop's environment stuff, this could turn out awesome.

27-09-2011 12:32 AM

Forgot to mention that me and Andy are going to be recording the whole thing and creating a time-lapse so that beginners can watch how we work. As Andy put it, our theme is "Do an interior - do whatever type we want". I will be posting my reference photo later tonight once I have finally decided on what it is.

27-09-2011 02:53 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Here's the reference that I finally decided on doing. I'm not planning on getting everything modeled out during this competition, just want to get something started for my reel.

Joopson 27-09-2011 06:16 AM

Ok, I'm going for a Gothic-style rotunda sort of thing, like the shot from Knights of the nine- but with a dome instead of that flat thing they put in. Stained glass, et cetera. Maybe put some cool cave-ish bits into the tunnels; or at least some broken ruin pieces. Should be very fun!

bullet1968 27-09-2011 06:38 AM

Very good I will be watching too LOL go fellas go

cheers bullet

27-09-2011 03:37 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I learned today that I am really slow at modeling. :/ Spent a lot of time blocking out the space. I still feel as if the scale is off.

Joopson 27-09-2011 04:28 PM

Long story short:
Felt like a huge jerk for neglecting my family- so I'm not doing this anymore. At least not today or during vacation.

JrWho is still doing his, though, on his own, and it will still turn out awesome. He's got skillz.- and I will do an environment like this soon, just not today or during vacation. It just seemed idiotic of me to spend one of my few days home doing something that I could do any day back in California. Darn guilt!

Sorry for the nonsense.

This is all I'd done.

honestdom 27-09-2011 04:55 PM


Originally Posted by Jr.Who (Post 325991)
I learned today that I am really slow at modeling. :/ Spent a lot of time blocking out the space. I still feel as if the scale is off.

i'd agree about the scale.

27-09-2011 08:07 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Spent some more time trying to fix the space and scale. Closer, but not quite there yet. Ran into at least three or four crashes already but nothing major. I've only done a couple basic interiors, so this one is definitely helping me learn some new stuff.

Also, the reason I'm being a douche and doing this while at home on break is because… well I live at home. Haha

bullet1968 27-09-2011 11:03 PM

1 Attachment(s)
For the scale mate I would do this (cant resist Im a Surveyor..sorry). Your average ceiling (well here in Australia) is approx 2.4...I have scaled this and got 48mm per actual metre. The angle is a bit hard but it will gove you basics. Standard door is 0.85 to 0.9 wide...I have checked this and got 0.85..which is close so my scale is correct. The floor width is 5.16...I would say more like 5.2m as unusual di mensions are rare. The stairway is a standard 1.2 m here...could be different in the States.

Pretty much I have opened it in Paint and NOT altered the image size when scaling. This is a standard thing I do when I do a room etc..I look for doors and assume ceiling height and go from there. You could even scale off the furniture and fireplace as well mate. Hope it has helped in some way.

cheers bullet

honestdom 28-09-2011 12:28 AM

if you are modeling the room. why not just line up the camera and model with this as the backplate?

28-09-2011 12:53 AM

4 Attachment(s)
bullet1968, thank you so much for that! I'll definitely use that advice when I open the file up again. I need to study more architecture. My biggest problem was with the camera angle and the stairs.

honestdom, I had a couple images in Maya, but I didn't use them much. I actually had an 18x12 print of it sitting next to me for reference.

I'm glad that I went along with this exercise. I learned quiet a bit while modeling and can't wait to get my time-lapse ready. Here's the renders. Please, feel free to give as much critique as you can, I certainly need it!

28-09-2011 12:54 AM

2 Attachment(s)
And two more.

All times are GMT. The time now is 05:45 PM.
Page 1 of 2 1 2

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Simply Maya 2018