Now... I'm going to stire this up a little and see where some of you can get with it.

Let's go a step further and say that ALL aspects of the situation were equal. Not only are the two apples equal, but the right and left sides of your body experience the same things and are not different from one another. The environment you are placed in is equal on both sides as well. NOW why did you choose the left apple over the right? Obviously, you cannot possibly use anything I stated above in the previous explanation because everything is equal.