I agree with hybrid. I voted for M.
JKLaroe's gun seemed very hard to tell.. the actual gun if you understand. seemed very basic and simple. Which isnt a bad thing all the time, simple can have amazing effects sometimes.. but it was too generic. Mybe a little more deffinition woudl help.
M's was well detailed and well designed compared to the original. very nice. The only comments is loking at the wireframe it looked like a lot of cylinders and so where barely edited but it did come out to the finished product excellently. so no complaints.
I think m's was better, more complex and all.. but if laroes gun was more detailed slightly, with a better render and orginization he had a serious chance to pull a come from behind.