Yeah the body needs to look a bit more "outhere" to match the face, his face looks "puffy" and sort of made up of fat mainly so I probably would not go with a toned look, I would try to keep is sleek, sort of seal/whale like if that makes sense, that way I feel it would fit with the character more.
Whats with the really high poly count?
"No pressure, no diamonds" Thomas Carlyle